Pizza restaurants

Nonno Sals

4.2 152 reviews 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM 1905 NJ-33, Hamilton Square, NJ 08690, United States

Discover this place

Nonno Sals, located in Hamilton Square, NJ, has quickly garnered a reputation as a local pizza gem. Customers rave about the quality of their food, particularly the pizza, which many declare as the best in the area. The fresh dough and flavorful toppings stand out, creating a delightful experience with every bite. As Kathleen Kearns aptly notes, attention to detail is evident, from beautifully crafted salads to the scrumptious, addicting pizzas. The diverse menu also features a variety of appetizers, specialty sandwiches, and soups, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Favorites include the crispy breaded mushrooms and the Chili Mango Calamari, which showcase the restaurant’s knack for delicious detail. Patrons like Stacey express their love not just for the pizza but for the overall dining experience, enhanced by efficient service and the convenience of app ordering through Slice. Nonno Sals has managed to cultivate a welcoming atmosphere alongside exceptional food, as highlighted by Bee Lemon, who appreciates their responsive customer service. If you're seeking a pizza destination where quality and customer care intersect, Nonno Sals is surely a place to indulge in flavorful delights that won't disappoint.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Nonno Sals before visiting.

Reviews for Nonno Sals

4.2

152 reviews

100%

24%

20%

Review highlights

Based on 152 reviews

Nonno Sals is widely praised for its consistently high-quality pizza, noted for fresh dough and flavorful options, particularly its Sicilian style. Customers appreciate the restaurant's attention to detail and the appealing presentation of its salads. The brand's meal delivery service receives positive remarks for reliability, timely fulfillment, and adherence to special instructions, often exceeding expectations despite occasional concerns about busyness. Additionally, Nonno Sals is recognized for its responsive and caring customer service, with many reviewers highlighting the brand’s efforts to engage with feedback and enhance the overall experience. Overall, Nonno Sals maintains a strong reputation as a standout pizza restaurant with dependable delivery in the Hamilton Square area.

Kathleen Kearns

May 12, 2025

Delicious every time we've ordered. The pizza dough is fresh and the salads are beautiful. Attention to detail is rare these days and is greatly appreciated! Would recommend. (We order thru "Slice" and they've been good too)

Martijn Pirozzi

Apr 22, 2025

This is hands down the best pizza in the area. Great quality every time we order.

Patrick Reisert

Mar 26, 2025

This Square Sicilian with sauce was amazing places is small, but pizza was pretty damn good.

Stacey

Mar 23, 2025

Have to edit this although I wish I could just add in another 5 star review: Slice app works! Don't listen to whoever said it didn't or that if it says that they are busier than usual means that they won't deliver. #1 yes they do deliver #2 it came faster than the app said #3 it was very hot! #4 they follow the instructions I left which was just to leave it and not knock so my dog wouldn't go crazy. Nono's omg: your pizza is addicting and the best. Never change you are a local treasure. Amazing pizza. You will not be disappointed. Ordered a large pepperoni and Hawaiian. The pizza is so flavorful I simply haven't tried anything like it. The price is a bit more than you'd expect for 2 pizzas (came out to 29tax) but after trying them out I was completely okay paying a premium for a premium slice of pizza.

Bee Lemon (Ayanna Hazzard)

Mar 09, 2025

Not only is this THE best pizza I've had in the area, but the customer service has consistently been lovely. And I appreciate seeing you respond to reviews and change and evolve based on them. Keep up the wonderful work.

Jeffrey Pummer

Mar 04, 2025

I order from Nonno Sals for local delivery. These guys are very solid and consistent. The prices are fair, and the service is great. For a local pizza joint, this is a win.

Maria Martin

Feb 21, 2025

I ordered through Uber eats delivery thought the food was delicious. Was cold when it got here but not the restaurants fault. And very reasonably priced seeing how everything seems to be more expensive these days.

L D

Feb 05, 2025

Consistent! All the food is delicious and fresh. Fresh hot pizza, tasty garlic knots, crunchy fresh salads and delicious cannolis. The other food is also tasty. I love the new grilled shrimp and chicken salad. Yum! The menu could use some new exciting options and we would love an expanded soup menu. We are loyal customers for years and have tried other pizza parlors. Nothing but regret and wasted money. You can’t go wrong with Nonno’s. Order fast and easy with the slice app or directly through the restaurant website. Both are delivered by restaurant employees versus gross third party delivery people.